The question I have been constantly asked since returning from our epic beer odyssey across the U.S. is "What was your favourite?""
Now I must admit that I have never had an instant answer as it is so subjective, and also dependant on what perspective you are asking from. For example are you asking what was the pub or brewery with the highest quality of beers which is an entirely different question compared to asking what pub or brewery did we have the best time at. An example of this was the Gingerman bar in Manhattan which had possibly one the best beer lists of the trip and a bar that was exquisitely furbished but our experience there was not enjoyable because we weren’t comfortable there at the end of the day when we were tired and just wanted to chill and relax. This results in what was one of the highest quality establishments we visited not being included or even considered as one of our favourites.
With a little bit of fond reviewing over the blogs later I was able to come up with a list of what I would loosely consider my top ten pubs and top five breweries from our odyssey.
Places that did not make the list, such as Dempseys Irish bar and St Andrews were great pubs in Manhattan where we had some of our greatest nights and are still strongly recommended. Other pubs such as McSorleys Ale house and the Great Jones Cafe are places that are certainly must visit destinations although once again not making the final list.
Without further ado, I rate the top ten pubs as follows:
1. Rattle n Hum - Manhattan. This is a pub that has an awesome tap list and good bottle selection set within a comfortable relaxed atmosphere that celebrates beer culture from wall to wall. They are constantly incorporating beer events and tap takeovers and most importantly will welcome everyone even if the world is about to end thanks to a hurricane.
2. The Toronado - San Fransisco. This pub was grungy, small and a bit of a hike but it was chocked full of character and a sense of real earthiness. More importantly the beer list, whilst not being the largest, was in my opinion the most dynamic, with an amazingly diverse selection of full flavour high quality beers sourced from throughout the West Coast.
3. Rogues Ale House - Newport Oregon. This pub was undoubtedly where we had the best of times and the place that many of us will return to at the soonest opportunity. At the Rogues Alehouse we experienced exceptionally friendly service and had at our disposal a great range of beers on tap (all from Rogues.) The apartments above the bar come with our highest recommendation.
4. Venice Ale house - Venice Beach L.A. This pub is located on the boardwalk looking out over the beach and made it up this high in the list due not just because of the great afternoon we had there but also thanks to great service and a really impressive beer list.
5. The Pub - Vegas baby Vegas. Unfortunately there aren’t many good places on the strip to find quality craft beer but this pub completely atones for it with one of the biggest ranges of beers encountered, trying the 17 different IPAs was enough to convince me. It was certainly the best sports bar we encountered throughout the trip with big LCD screens everywhere and flatbread that was outstanding.
6. The Freakin Frog - Vegas. This place is off the strip in Vegas and has probably the best cool room with racks and racks of bottles from all over the world.
7. The Blind Tiger - Manhattan. One of the greatest ale houses New York has to offer with an ever changing and exciting tap list. Definitely a must visit pub if you are ever in New York.
8. Hop Devil Grill - Manhattan. This was another cool pub on the trendy east side with an exciting beer list and a ridiculous all you can drink Sunday brunch special.
9. The Pony - Manhattan. Just another of Manhattans great bars offering great beers that also provides high quality food to match. Many New York bars (and I mean awesome bars) missed out but the line had to be drawn somewhere, it must be said that the overall quality and range of bars in New York was a dream.
10. Doyles - Boston and Kellys - Portland. I feel compelled to include an Irish pub and I couldn't split the difference between these two deserved Irish bars - they both had great ranges of beer and the quintessential Irish drinking atmosphere to compliment the always appreciated well poured Guinness. Furthermore I would love to have either of them as my local.
Now as for the breweries I wish I had got to more but is what turned out to be an obvious top five;
1. Russian River - California. The most amazing beers were tasted here with great IPAs such as the famous Pliny the Elder, and beers cask-conditioned in oak wine barrels. Simply amazing.
2. Bear Republic - California. These guys have my favourite branding by using the old Speed Racer style theme. More importantly, the beers are fantastic and once again provided diversity at the top end with Barley wines, IPAs and oak aged beers. They are truly one of Americas greatest breweries, the good news is that The Wheaty has just received a shipment and have some in stock.
3. Stone Brewing - San Diego. Simply one of the best breweries in the world and I was disspointed not to have the time to take the tour. I was however able to sample some of their outstanding range of beers from a list that once again providing high end options with oaked ales, barley wines and quality IPAs. The brewery is a must visit destination for a meal, just make sure you give yourself time to sample more than one or two beers to do it justice.
4. Rogues HQ, Brewers on the Bay - Newport Oregon. Rogue Headquarters....what can I say about a personal favourite, it’s worth a brewery tour for sure, then take a quick visit to the gift shop before settling in to try their beers pint by pint. It's the XS range (their premium limited issue beers) such as imperial IPAs and stouts that are particularly of interest. It appears that every Rogue pub (including the ale house over the bridge) have different XS kegs and bottles allocated to them so don't think for a minute that once you have visited one site that you should leave it at that.
5. Lagunitas Brewing, California. A great spot to spend a Sunday arvo in their beer garden sampling their hoppy beery goodness.
Now it must be said that every one of us on the tour may have slightly different answers as to what their favourite drinking hole would have been. But isn’t this the whole point, that we get off our butts, get out there to explore this new found diverse beer world in which we all can find our own personal mecca. It's this process that is the adventure during which memories are created to last a life time. The bonus side effect is that we may just find our own new next favourite drinking spot or favourite beer and then be able to sit down with mates and share either the beer or the story.
Thanks again for the support of Lavina Estate wines and the Wheatsheaf Hotel.
Cheers all, see you at a bar somewhere soon.


















